Morris County Chamber of Commerce
  • JOIN
    • Become a Member
    • Premier Membership
    • Membership Inquiry
    • The Value of Membership >
      • Grow Your Business
      • Build Your Brand
      • Professional Development & Education
      • Government Advocacy
      • Community Outreach & Volunteering
    • New Member Survey
  • About
    • Chamber Team
    • Our Mission
    • Our President
    • Board of Directors
    • Morris Business Cabinet
    • President's Circle
    • Ambassadors Council
    • What Members Are Saying >
      • Share a Testimonial
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Forums & Committees >
      • Business Development Forum
      • Business Strategy Exchange
      • Health & Wellness Forum
      • Human Resources Committee
      • Not For Profit Roundtable >
        • Nonprofit Donations
      • Real Estate Forum
      • Sustainability Forum
      • Tech Trends
      • Women in Business Program
      • Young Professionals Forum
      • Monthly Agenda Submission Form
    • Code of Conduct & COVID Policy
  • Membership
    • Member Benefits
    • Member to Member Deals
    • Member Exchange Online Community
    • Member Marketing Opportunities
    • Grand Opening Support
    • Conference Room Usage
    • Member Referral Bonus
    • Connect to Morris Job Bank
  • Events
    • Chamber Event Calendar
    • Member Events Calendar
    • Signature Events & Programs
    • NFP Nominations 2023
    • Not For Profit Conference Scholarship App
    • Golf Committee Volunteers
    • Golf Donations 2023
    • Submit an Event Idea
  • Directory
    • Searchable Business Directory
    • Member Spotlights
    • Nonprofit Organizations >
      • Not for Profit Spotlight
    • Legal Resources >
      • Employment Law
      • Commercial Services
      • Business Representation
      • General Legal
    • Enhance Your Directory Listing
  • News & Info
    • Certificate of Origin
    • Business Resources
    • Chamber Magazines
    • News Around the Chamber >
      • Around the Chamber Archive
      • Submit a Press Release
      • Submit a Neighbors Helping Neighbors Story
    • MCCC Blog >
      • Contribute to Our Blog
    • MCTV Let's Talk
    • Actionable Advice Video Library
  • Programs
    • Economic Development Corp
    • EDC Business Counseling
    • Public Policy Series
    • Leadership Morris >
      • Leadership Morris FAQs
      • Leadership Morris Application
      • Leadership Morris Program
      • Leadership Morris Alumni Council
      • Renew LMAA Membership
    • Women In Business >
      • Women in Business Mastermind
      • Women in Business Executive Round Table
      • Women in Golf Program
    • Entrepreneur Round Table
    • Intern Morris >
      • Available Internships
      • Hiring An Intern?
      • Hire an MCVSD Intern
    • Thrive Morris
  • Member Portal

MCCC Blog

Click Here to submit an article for our blog. 
Note: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the position of the Morris County Chamber of Commerce.

Sham Paper Trail Won’t Protect You if You Misclassify Employees

8/11/2022

 
Picture
By Lisa I. Fried-Grodin, Esq., Fried-Grodin Employment Law
In early August, the New Jersey Supreme Court has just sent a strong message to companies that try to justify classifying workers as independent contractors without a legitimate basis to do so. The message: Don’t try to cover up an actual employment relationship by relying on a document trail designed to make a worker look like a contractor when the documents do not reflect reality. 
In East By Drywall v. Department of Labor, A-7 September Term 2021 085770, A-7-21 - East Bay Drywall, LLC v. Department of Labor and Workforce Development (085770) A-7-21 - East Bay Drywall, LLC v. Department of Labor and Workforce Development (085770) (Statewide) (njcourts.gov), the East by Drywall hired a combination of business entities and workers (16 in total) to do its work (installing, taping and finishing drywalling in residential homes) over a three-year period. Once the company secured a drywall job, the Principal would look for workers and require each worker/entity to provide a certificate of insurance and tax id number to “ensure they were independent businesses”.

East Bay Drywall set the pay these workers would receive, provided them with the materials to do the work, maintained responsibility for the finished product, paid them when the job was done and issued a 1099 to each worker/entity. Most of the workers provided their own tools, some left the project before it was finished if they got a better job, and some told the Principal they worked for other businesses (but the Principal had no actual proof that was true). The state’s highest court found that all 16 of these employees were not independent contractors but actually misclassified as employees because despite the paper trail, East Bay Drywall did not present sufficient evidence that all of these workers/entities were actually maintaining businesses that were separate and part from East Bay Drywall.

Satisfying this requirement is one of the three requirements for establishing independent contractor status under New Jersey’s ABC test. The essence of the ABC test is that a worker is an employee unless the individual is
(A) “free from control or direction” and
(B) providing service that is “outside the usual course of the business” or “performed outside of all the places of business of the enterprise for which such service is performed;” and
(C) “customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, profession or business.” N.J.S.A. 43:21-19(i)(6).

Because all of the business registrations showed only one individual in the ownership structure and throughout the time these individuals worked for East Bay, their business registrations and certificates of insurance were not active for the full period of work, the Court agreed with the New Jersey Department of Labor that these documents did not show that these businesses were active independent business. That fact combined with the fact that East Bay did not present evidence that these workers/entities had independent business locations, other customers, advertised or had employees led the Court to conclude that these entities were independent entities in name only.

“A business practice that requires workers to assume the appearance of an independent business entity – a company in name only – could give rise to an inference that such a practice was intended to obscure the employer’s responsibility to remit its [unemployment] fund contributions as mandated by the state’s employee protection statutes,” Judge Jose Fuentes wrote in the opinion. “That type of subterfuge is particularly damaging in the construction context, where workers may be less likely to be familiar with the public policy protections afforded by the ABC test and consequently particularly vulnerable to the manipulation of the laws intended to protect all employees,” he said.

As a result of this misclassification, this employer owes $42,120 to the state for unpaid unemployment and temporary disability contributions. The New Jersey Department of Labor hailed the decision as a significant victory for its enforcement efforts. Given the prevalence of remote work and the ambiguity of part B of the ABC test which requires that an independent contractor perform services “outside the usual course of the business” or “outside of all the places of business”, in the Opinion, the Court suggests that the NJDOL issue regulations providing clarity on what these terms mean.

This case highlights the point that analyzing whether or not a worker is an employee or independent contractor is fact-sensitive. Employers who get it wrong face potentially significant consequences in the form of criminal penalties and civil fines, penalties and damages. Independent contractors cannot collect unemployment benefits, temporary disability benefits and generally have less rights than employees. An employee who is misclassified as an independent contractor will forfeit those rights if they don’t challenge their misclassification. Fried-Grodin Employment Law regularly helps employers and employees understand and ensure that workers are properly classified.

​This article originally appeared on friedgrodinlaw.com

Comments are closed.

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019

    Categories

    All
    Around The Chamber
    Business Advice
    Business Development
    Business Edge Magazine
    Chamber News
    Coaching
    Entrepreneurs
    Events
    Finance
    Government Affairs
    Health & Wellness
    IT
    Leadership Morris
    Legal
    Manufacturing
    Marketing
    Message From The President
    Nonprofit
    Real Estate
    Sales Strategy
    Seniors
    Strategic Planning
    Women In Business

    RSS Feed

    Please Note: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the position of the Morris County Chamber of Commerce.
Picture
JOIN Us   |   CONTACT Us  |  LEARN About Membership  |  REGISTER for Events  |  FIND a Member Business  |  READ our Magazines  |  LEAD Morris |  FAQ

Picture
325 Columbia Turnpike, ​​Suite 101
Florham Park, NJ 07932 

​973.539.3882 | CONTACT US | ​MAP
If you plan to stop by, it's best to make an appointment to ensure that someone will be available for you.
The Power of Connection!  Your membership connects you to valuable resources, opportunities for business growth and rewarding relationships with members across the region, in-person and virtually. And you don't need to be based in Morris County to join!  Your membership investment provides a stable foundation that enables us to serve the people who power Morris County's businesses and community.
STAY CONNECTED: ​SIGN UP FOR UPDATES!
Socialize with Us!
Site Map

ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Picture
TOURISM BUREAU
Picture
PROUD MEMBER OF
Picture
PROUD MEMBER OF
Picture
PROUD MEMBER OF
Picture
PROUD MEMBER OF
Picture
PROUD MEMBER OF
Picture

©2023 Morris County Chamber of Commerce  |  A 501(c)(6) nonprofit membership organization
  • JOIN
    • Become a Member
    • Premier Membership
    • Membership Inquiry
    • The Value of Membership >
      • Grow Your Business
      • Build Your Brand
      • Professional Development & Education
      • Government Advocacy
      • Community Outreach & Volunteering
    • New Member Survey
  • About
    • Chamber Team
    • Our Mission
    • Our President
    • Board of Directors
    • Morris Business Cabinet
    • President's Circle
    • Ambassadors Council
    • What Members Are Saying >
      • Share a Testimonial
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Forums & Committees >
      • Business Development Forum
      • Business Strategy Exchange
      • Health & Wellness Forum
      • Human Resources Committee
      • Not For Profit Roundtable >
        • Nonprofit Donations
      • Real Estate Forum
      • Sustainability Forum
      • Tech Trends
      • Women in Business Program
      • Young Professionals Forum
      • Monthly Agenda Submission Form
    • Code of Conduct & COVID Policy
  • Membership
    • Member Benefits
    • Member to Member Deals
    • Member Exchange Online Community
    • Member Marketing Opportunities
    • Grand Opening Support
    • Conference Room Usage
    • Member Referral Bonus
    • Connect to Morris Job Bank
  • Events
    • Chamber Event Calendar
    • Member Events Calendar
    • Signature Events & Programs
    • NFP Nominations 2023
    • Not For Profit Conference Scholarship App
    • Golf Committee Volunteers
    • Golf Donations 2023
    • Submit an Event Idea
  • Directory
    • Searchable Business Directory
    • Member Spotlights
    • Nonprofit Organizations >
      • Not for Profit Spotlight
    • Legal Resources >
      • Employment Law
      • Commercial Services
      • Business Representation
      • General Legal
    • Enhance Your Directory Listing
  • News & Info
    • Certificate of Origin
    • Business Resources
    • Chamber Magazines
    • News Around the Chamber >
      • Around the Chamber Archive
      • Submit a Press Release
      • Submit a Neighbors Helping Neighbors Story
    • MCCC Blog >
      • Contribute to Our Blog
    • MCTV Let's Talk
    • Actionable Advice Video Library
  • Programs
    • Economic Development Corp
    • EDC Business Counseling
    • Public Policy Series
    • Leadership Morris >
      • Leadership Morris FAQs
      • Leadership Morris Application
      • Leadership Morris Program
      • Leadership Morris Alumni Council
      • Renew LMAA Membership
    • Women In Business >
      • Women in Business Mastermind
      • Women in Business Executive Round Table
      • Women in Golf Program
    • Entrepreneur Round Table
    • Intern Morris >
      • Available Internships
      • Hiring An Intern?
      • Hire an MCVSD Intern
    • Thrive Morris
  • Member Portal