Morris County Chamber of Commerce
  • JOIN
    • Become a Member
    • Premier Membership
    • What Members Are Saying >
      • Share a Testimonial
    • Membership Inquiry
    • The Value of Membership >
      • Grow Your Business
      • Build Your Brand
      • Professional Development & Education
      • Government Advocacy
      • Community Outreach & Volunteering
    • New Member Survey
    • Power of Connection
  • About
    • Chamber Team
    • Our Mission
    • Our President
    • Board of Directors
    • Morris Business Cabinet
    • President's Circle
    • Chamber Champions
    • Ambassadors Council
    • Inclusivity Advisory Council
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Code of Conduct & COVID Policy
  • Membership
    • Member Benefits
    • Forums & Committees >
      • Business Development Forum
      • Business Strategy Forum
      • Health & Wellness Forum
      • Not For Profit Roundtable
      • Real Estate Forum
      • RISE Morris: Young Professionals Forum
      • Women in Business Program >
        • WIB Event Committee
    • Member to Member Deals
    • Member Marketing Opportunities
    • Grand Opening Support
    • Conference Room Usage
    • Member Referral Bonus
    • Connect to Morris Job Bank
  • Events
    • Chamber Event Calendar
    • Member Events Calendar
    • Signature Events & Programs
    • Golf Donations 2025
    • Event Photos
    • Submit an Event Idea
    • CCM Grant-Supported Training
  • Directory
    • Searchable Business Directory
    • Nonprofit Giving Guide 2024
    • Member Spotlights
    • Legal Resources >
      • Employment Law
      • Commercial Services
      • Business Representation
      • General Legal
    • Enhance Your Directory Listing
  • News & Info
    • Electronic Certificate of Origin
    • Business Resources & Info
    • Chamber Magazines
    • News Around the Chamber >
      • Around the Chamber Archive
      • Submit a Press Release
    • MCCC Blog >
      • Contribute to Our Blog
    • Members Library Submission
    • MCTV Let's Talk
    • Actionable Advice Video Library
  • Programs
    • Economic Development Corp
    • EDC Business Counseling
    • Public Policy Series
    • CEO Round Table
    • Lead Morris >
      • Lead Morris Program
      • Lead Morris Alumni Council
      • LEAD Morris Alumni Directory
      • Lead Morris FAQs
      • Lead Morris Application
      • LEAD Morris News & Info
      • Share a LEAD Morris Testimonial
    • Women In Business >
      • Women in Business Mastermind
      • Women in Business Executive Round Table
      • Women in Golf Program
    • Entrepreneur Roundtable
    • Thrive Morris >
      • Thrive Morris Community Leaders
      • Thrive Morris Blog
      • Contribute to the Thrive Morris Blog
  • Member Portal

MCCC Blog

Click Here to submit an article for our blog. 
Note: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the position of the Morris County Chamber of Commerce.

Real Estate Lessons Learned from Covid-19: A Review of Recent Precedent on Lease Clauses

7/15/2021

 
Picture
By Jonathan B. King, Porzio Bromberg & Newman, P.C.
As every commercial landlord or tenant is doubtless aware, the Covid-19 pandemic and resulting business closures wreaked havoc on the commercial leasing realm, impacting just about every tenant's ability to conduct business, generate revenue, and pay rent. Amidst the wreckage, a coast-to-coast legal battle has raged from the beginning of the economic shutdown and continuing through this day and beyond, as to one central question: Should the landlord or the tenant absorb the costs of a global pandemic that nobody anticipated? 
Everyday lease provisions contemplate and manage certain common risks – the risk of fire, utility outage, even that a government entity condemns a portion of the property. Nobody anticipated Covid-19, and few built the risk of a virtual economic standstill into their leases. The Reality of Force Majeure Grasping for any lease guidance on this question, landlords, tenants and counsel headed straight for the force majeure clause. This clause contemplates remote risks such as war, rebellion, an act of God, and yes, even pandemic. Still, virtually every incarnation of such language provides that no such drastic event would forgive the payment of rent by the tenant to a landlord. So, in trying to provide clarity and comfort going forward, landlords, tenants, and counsel could make sure that "pandemic" and "government-ordered shutdown" are included in every force majeure clause from this day on, but no landlord is likely to agree to excuse rent for these causes, any more than they were previously willing to excuse rent for a nuclear calamity.

However, several issues emerging from the pandemic provide insight that review and careful negotiation of other standard lease provisions—provisions that should have required close attention all along—can help manage lingering Covid-19 and future pandemic risks. Lease Guaranty Provisions A recent case in New York highlights the importance of lease guaranty provisions. Many business owners may not want to give a personal guaranty of their entity's lease. Yet, many landlords will require a guaranty because a tenant LLC or corporation could close operations and leave rent obligations unpaid. In 135 E. 57th St., LLC v. Saks Inc., a case involving Saks Fifth Avenue, the retailer argued that not only should its tenant affiliate be excused from performance under government shutdown conditions, but the Saks corporate parent, as guarantor, should also be off the hook. The Court disagreed as to the guarantor, ruling that any eviction moratorium applied only to the tenant and not the enforcement of a corporate guaranty. The lesson learned is that it may always be best to negotiate a guaranty to control where the guarantor's liability may be different or deeper than that of the tenant.

For example, a lease could include a "good-guy" clause where the guarantor is released from liability as long as the tenant surrenders the space with the rent paid to date. Continuous Operations Clause Another common lease clause that carries implications for a pandemic or government-shutdown conditions is the continuous operation clause. This language, most common in the retail setting, requires that the tenant open for business and remain open on a steady basis, without, for example, closing a store or restaurant for a vacation period. Clearly, this lease requirement was front and center where the conduct of many retail businesses became difficult or impossible amid government shutdowns, but courts in the Covid-19 era have not been unanimous as to what is required to constitute the legal defenses of "frustration of purpose" or "impossibility." While the continuous operation requirement, unlike the payment of rent, would arguably be excused under force majeure conditions, careful lease drafting should specify what extraordinary conditions would excuse the tenant from continuous operation.

Permitted Use Clause

​Finally, the Covid-19 emergency has highlighted the need to carefully review the permitted use clause in every lease. In most cases, the tenant's counsel should be working to expand the definition of permitted use of the space. The expansion of the definition of permitted use could help protect the tenant from a claim of lease violation. For example, a clause that only provides "office use" could leave the tenant susceptible for hosting a conference that is not a specifically enumerated use. However, as mentioned, courts have not been uniform in determining the impact of government shutdown orders on tenant operations, with some holding a restaurant's ability to conduct curbside or take-out business meant that the tenant's "use" of the restaurant premises was not impossible. Alternatively, a Massachusetts court held that the inability to host patrons for sit-down service made a "café" use substantially impossible. In Newbury v. Caffe Nero Americas Inc. the tenant and its counsel may be happy that they did not go further in expanding the definition of "permitted use." The Covid-19 pandemic illustrates that it is crucial for landlords, tenants, and counsel to craft a permitted use clause, and other routine lease clauses, with as much precision as possible.

Comments are closed.

    Archives

    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019

    Categories

    All
    Around The Chamber
    Business Advice
    Business Development
    Business Edge Magazine
    Chamber News
    Coaching
    Entrepreneurs
    Events
    Finance
    Government Affairs
    Health & Wellness
    Human Resources
    IT
    Leadership Morris
    Legal
    Manufacturing
    Marketing
    Message From The President
    Nonprofit
    Real Estate
    Sales Strategy
    Seniors
    Strategic Planning
    Women In Business


    Please Note: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the position of the Morris County Chamber of Commerce.
Picture
JOIN Us   |   CONTACT Us  |  LEARN About Membership  |  REGISTER for Events  |  FIND a Member Business  |  READ our Magazines  |  LEAD Morris |  FAQ

Picture
325 Columbia Turnpike, ​​Suite 101
Florham Park, NJ 07932 

​973.539.3882 | CONTACT US | ​MAP
STAY CONNECTED: ​SIGN UP FOR UPDATES!
The Power of Connection!  Your membership connects you to valuable resources, opportunities for business growth and rewarding relationships with fellow members. And you don't need to be based in Morris County to belong!  
Our Business Hours are Monday to Friday, 9 am to 5 pm.  If you plan to stop by, it's best to make an appointment to ensure that someone will be available for you. Staff is often out of the office hosting events or meeting with members.
Follow  Us! 
The Morris County Economic Development Alliance (The Alliance) is an affiliated 501c3 Nonprofit of the Morris County Chamber and includes the Morris County Tourism Bureau, the Morris County Economic Development Corporation and the Connect To Morris job board.

©2025 Morris County Chamber of Commerce  |  A 501(c)(6) nonprofit membership organization  |  Site Map
  • JOIN
    • Become a Member
    • Premier Membership
    • What Members Are Saying >
      • Share a Testimonial
    • Membership Inquiry
    • The Value of Membership >
      • Grow Your Business
      • Build Your Brand
      • Professional Development & Education
      • Government Advocacy
      • Community Outreach & Volunteering
    • New Member Survey
    • Power of Connection
  • About
    • Chamber Team
    • Our Mission
    • Our President
    • Board of Directors
    • Morris Business Cabinet
    • President's Circle
    • Chamber Champions
    • Ambassadors Council
    • Inclusivity Advisory Council
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Code of Conduct & COVID Policy
  • Membership
    • Member Benefits
    • Forums & Committees >
      • Business Development Forum
      • Business Strategy Forum
      • Health & Wellness Forum
      • Not For Profit Roundtable
      • Real Estate Forum
      • RISE Morris: Young Professionals Forum
      • Women in Business Program >
        • WIB Event Committee
    • Member to Member Deals
    • Member Marketing Opportunities
    • Grand Opening Support
    • Conference Room Usage
    • Member Referral Bonus
    • Connect to Morris Job Bank
  • Events
    • Chamber Event Calendar
    • Member Events Calendar
    • Signature Events & Programs
    • Golf Donations 2025
    • Event Photos
    • Submit an Event Idea
    • CCM Grant-Supported Training
  • Directory
    • Searchable Business Directory
    • Nonprofit Giving Guide 2024
    • Member Spotlights
    • Legal Resources >
      • Employment Law
      • Commercial Services
      • Business Representation
      • General Legal
    • Enhance Your Directory Listing
  • News & Info
    • Electronic Certificate of Origin
    • Business Resources & Info
    • Chamber Magazines
    • News Around the Chamber >
      • Around the Chamber Archive
      • Submit a Press Release
    • MCCC Blog >
      • Contribute to Our Blog
    • Members Library Submission
    • MCTV Let's Talk
    • Actionable Advice Video Library
  • Programs
    • Economic Development Corp
    • EDC Business Counseling
    • Public Policy Series
    • CEO Round Table
    • Lead Morris >
      • Lead Morris Program
      • Lead Morris Alumni Council
      • LEAD Morris Alumni Directory
      • Lead Morris FAQs
      • Lead Morris Application
      • LEAD Morris News & Info
      • Share a LEAD Morris Testimonial
    • Women In Business >
      • Women in Business Mastermind
      • Women in Business Executive Round Table
      • Women in Golf Program
    • Entrepreneur Roundtable
    • Thrive Morris >
      • Thrive Morris Community Leaders
      • Thrive Morris Blog
      • Contribute to the Thrive Morris Blog
  • Member Portal